Rated 3 out of 5 by 6
Rated 2 out of 5 by Verified Reviewer Poor Quality
Edge started to fray on second day of use. Does not seem durable especially for price.
June 16, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by Patrick3 So far so good
I've used this wallet daily for a month, and it's working well--we'll see in several months, but nothing has failed. The ID holder is useful for my ID to get into my office; there are enough card slots for everything, and the leather is thinner and stretchy but solid enough.
May 29, 2016
Rated 2 out of 5 by First bad experience Very Disappointed
I ordered this Allen Edmonds Card Case with ID Holder and have been using it since April 26, 2016 until now. Last weekend I noticed the surround edge had come off. I called the customer service for a refund. I will never buy that kind again. I like a lot of products made by AE but not this one.
May 17, 2016
Rated 3 out of 5 by Kevin C. Not AE Quality
I'm disappointed in the durability of this wallet. I'm a big fan of Allen Edmonds, and have been extremely satisfied with all of the many shoes, belts, shirts, and sweaters I have purchased over the years. When my last wallet finally gave up after 4 years, I wanted something that would be more durable and at the same time more attractive, and I figured that was right up the AE alley. Well, this wallet certainly is well designed for aesthetics and ease of card storage/removal.
Unfortunately, even though it's about as slim as my previous Nixon wallet, it is already falling apart after only 6 months. The leather is getting ragged and has been dyed blue (though my same pair of jeans did not do that to my other wallet), and the piping around the leather is falling off. I'm by no means hard on it, in fact for half the time it stays neatly tucked away in my suitcase while I'm overseas at work.
Being that the Nixon wallet was half the price and lasted 6 times as long, unfortunately I think I will go back to that one.
April 5, 2015