Catalina Soft Penny Loafer


Item# SF2243
$295.00 $199.97


  • Select Color 2243 Tan

Product Actions

Add to cart options

Additional Information



  • Elegance blended with classic American style
  • Supple, soft comfort and iconic style
  • Classic fit with a relaxed attitude
  • Built on the 554 Last


  • Wraps your feet in softness
  • SurfForm™ Insole, lined with supple Janus Leather
  • Removable Insole to accommodate custom orthotics
  • Rubber crepe outsole for stability and anti-slip performance
  • Craft

  • Handsewn construction
  • High quality Janus calf hide for ultra-soft feel
  • Recraftable
  • Imported
  • Care

    Care Instructions

    STEP 1: Thoroughly remove dirt, scuffs and stains using our Suede and Nubuck Cleaning System, following the instructions on the box.

    STEP 2: Once the material has dried, spray our Suede Protector over the surface of the shoes. Apply regularly between cleanings.

    STEP 3: When not in use, store in Shoe Bag to protect from dust and dirt.


    Relaxed Fit

    The relaxed fit has added space in the toe box. This extra room allows for thicker socks and foot expansion that occurs at the end of the day or during a long flight.

    U.S. E.U. U.K.
    5 38 4
    5.5 38.5 4.5
    6 39 5.5
    6.5 39.5 6
    7 40 6.5
    7.5 41 7
    8 41.5 7.5
    8.5 42 8
    9 43 8.5
    9.5 43.5 9
    10 44 9.5
    10.5 44.5 10
    11 45 10.5
    11.5 45.5 11
    12 46 11.5
    12.5 47 12
    13 48 12.5
    14 49 13
    15 50 14
    16 50.5 15

    For help getting the perfect fit, we recommend you visit a retail store to get your feet fitted. If you do not have the option to visit one of our stores, you may contact customer service to help you choose the right size.

    Width Available Sizes
    AAAA 8.5-16 Narrow
    AAA 10-12, 13, 14
    AA 10-12, 13, 14
    A 9-12, 13, 14
    B 8-12, 13, 14, 15
    C 8-12, 13, 14, 15
    D 6-13, 14, 15, 16 Medium
    E 6-12, 13, 14
    EE 6-12, 13
    EEE 7-12, 13, 14 Wide


    We believe making a great pair of shoes or boots is a long-term commitment. That’s why we construct our styles with handcrafted bench welts, ensuring our experts can rebuild your footwear and you can count on years of exceptional wear.

    Our recrafting service saves over 70,000 pairs of shoes from landfills each year.

    From refinishing the uppers to replacing the soles, we offer a full range of packages for extending the lifespan of our timeless designs.

    Ask & Answer
    Catalina Soft Penny Loafer is rated 4.3 out of 5 by 3.
    Rated 5 out of 5 by from Great look and feel Shoe fits snug at first but breaks in so well. The crepe sole is wonderful! Never had a more comfortable sole in my life.
    Date published: 2020-08-12
    Rated 5 out of 5 by from Nice Casual Loafers, Good Snug Fit I'm very happy with these loafers, which are intentionally very casual in their styling. They are obviously designed with warm weather in mind, with almost a "slouchy" vibe that I think is great. I really like the fit. The insoles say "The Catalina: Made for Bare Feet," and I feel like AE did a great job designing a snug, lower volume last that fits well without socks. The shoes are VERY snug when brand new, but quickly soften up around your foot. I am a D width, but I'm on the skinnier, lower-volume side of a D so that I commonly struggle with heal slip and overall looseness on loafers. However, the Catalina hug my feet beautifully with no heel slip at all, while taking my usual AE size. Somehow, this snug-but-comfortable fit is achieved without the shoe being short and stubby...the Catalina is actually on the longer side for a moc toe loafer. The shoes also make your foot appear relatively long for this style of shoe (which is a good thing IMO - I don't like the short & stubby look). For example, I had the AE Sea Island (AE's previous summer penny loafer), and the Catalina have a much longer appearance, and actually measure longer along the bottom of the sole in the same size, without any major difference in fit. I got the Taupe color, which are pretty accurate to the pics. Most ppl would probably think "gray" when seeing them, as opposed to taupe. The nap of the suede does make for light and dark tones across the shoe, which goes with the casual, broken-in style.
    Date published: 2020-07-06
    Rated 3 out of 5 by from Runs Small Was a full size too small - I think largely due to the inline/inside design of the shoe. I'm not sure a bigger size would have help though, because the length was fine. Not sure about this design!
    Date published: 2020-09-07
    • y_2021, m_6, d_10, h_18
    • bvseo_bulk, prod_bvrr, vn_bulk_3.0.17
    • cp_1, bvpage1
    • co_hasreviews, tv_0, tr_3
    • loc_, sid_SF2243, prod, sort_[SortEntry(order=RATING, direction=DESCENDING), SortEntry(order=FEATURED, direction=DESCENDING), SortEntry(order=SUBMISSION_TIME, direction=DESCENDING)]
    • clientName_allenedmonds

    Recently Viewed